Most payphones have two keys – one for the top compartment and one for the vault (coin box). Once the lock is open, you need to turn the T-key (two equivalent types are pictured below) to actually disengage the locking mechanism. There are different types of locks. Opening a phone without the key can be a challenge. Various methods will be discussed here.
This is still work-in-progress page, your feedback and input is highly appreciated!
There are three main types of US single-slot payphones: Western Electric (coin slot and return on the left-hand side, handset cord sticking out from the front), GTE/Quadrum (coin slot and return on the right-hand side, handset cord on the side), and Nortel Millennium. Actually, the GTE looks slightly different from the Quadrum pictured below – the coin return lever is underneath the coin slot – but they are generally considered the same type.
Proceed with WE or GTE lock section accordingly.
Various links / documents:
WE locks are used in single-slot WE payphones (coin return on the left) and Nortel Millennium phones. The top and bottom locks are interchangeable, but normally a different lock is used for the coin box. Millennium needs a slightly different lock for the coin box – there is a notch for the lock sensor.
WE 29A – typically used for the top compartment in both WE-style and Millennium phones, but usually by large Telcos (former US West/Qwest, for example). Notice the deep cut in the key; this is typical for 29 locks. There is a limited number of key combinations, and they are common for one region. It is possible to order one if the region/key number is known. It is also relatively easy to pick. Some western style phones (the AT&T private payphone, for example) use a 29B lock, which I believe is functionally the same as a 29A, except they were all keyed differently.

WE 30 A/B/C – typically used for the vault door. Nearly impossible to pick or drill. There are millions of key combinations. To open it, different methods need to be used rather than drilling/picking the lock. See notes by Matt Blaze. A slightly different variant was used with AT&T private payphones.

Medeco – this can be seen mostly in Nortel Millennium phones (both top and bottom), but some WE-style phones also used it, mostly for the vault door. It is possible to drill (although not very easily), but it is difficult to pick: each of the four pins inside has to be turned in the right direction as well. Unlike a typical Schlage key, where you just need to raise the pin to the shear line, you also need to rotate the Medeco pin in the right direction. If you look at a Medeco key, you'll see that some cuts are to the right, some are to the left, and some are in the center.
GTE/Quadrum types are effectively the same design in different housings. The upper lock on a GTE-style phone has only three pins.
Abloy – mostly used by COCOTs (private companies), one of the largest being FSH, both in WE-style phones (often made by Elcotel) and possibly Millennium phones (it has a notch for the sensor). Not to be confused with the GTE/Quadrum type. Relatively easy to defeat – especially when installed in the top compartment.
Top locks are of various types, including Medeco, Abloy, and generic ones, but they look similar – basically a bare cylinder and a mounting nut. The pictures below show the most common type (Medeco) with a standard BJ0004 key. This is one of the types supplied by GTE as a factory default, before the COCOT company applied its own lock. If you're lucky, BJ0004 (available online) may open it, but if the phone was removed from the street, the chances are low. There are certain ways to open it.
Bottom locks also exist in different models: Abloy (pictured below), Medeco, and various generic ones. There are certain ways to unlock them; however, an air chisel is NOT recommended here.
This is not always working but might be worth trying. If unsuccessful, it still makes it easier for potential drilling of the lock. All pictures © Andy Krop.
GTE/Quadrum are typically possible to open by means of drilling or air-chiseling the lock. With WE 30A/B/C locks though, it is challenging. In some cases the time is limited to remove the phone too. There are some slightly destructive methods in use.

Tools required:
Always wear protective glasses and gloves. Grinding process may cause severe injuries.
(by Jeff Popp)
This method only works with WE-style phones (coin return on the left). First remove the upper housing. From the right edge of the vault door, measure 1/4 to 3/8 of an inch in (this is where the surface becomes flat) and mark a line up and down the vault door. Take the grinder – a smaller disc – and grind along the line you marked. Once you have cut through the door at the top and bottom. Grind further in at the center of the vault door, using a larger disc (4.5“) at least 1½ inches deep. Make sure you're grinding exactly perpendicular to the vault door surface. You will know you cut through the locks hardened steel. Then take your J-Bar to unlock the door. It may turn a bit, then continue cutting – you may need to repeat it 3 times.

(by Jeff Popp)
First remove the upper housing. From the right edge of the vault door, measure 5/8 of an inch in and mark a line up and down the vault door with a pencil. Take the grinder and grind along the line you marked. Once you have cut through the door at the top and bottom. Grind further in at the center of the vault door, at least 1½ inches. You will know you cut through the locks hardened steel. Then take your J-Bar to unlock the door. You may need to play around with the J-Bar for a bit to get the vault door off.
Pictures: 1) after successful removal, 2) rear view of the vault door – where you cut, 3) technician cutting the vault door due to the lock damage
This method was developed by Bell. It's proven to work, but needs much more time and effort than using angle grinder. It is cleaner and more quiet though, so in some cases might work better.
Instructions - page 1
Instructions - page 2
Visio cut-out pattern to be printed on 4x6 sheet - by Shane Young (pdf & vsdx)